IN THE UNITED STATES CLAIMS COURT
CASE NO. 581-88T
FILED
OCT 15 1990
CHURCH OF SPIRITUAL TECHNOLOGY,
Plaintiff,
V.
THE UNITED STATES,
Defendant.
PLAINTIFF’S PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT1
Monique E. Yingling
ZUCKERT, SCOUTT & RASENBERGER
888 Seventeenth Street, N.W. Suite 600
Washington, D.C. 20006 202/298-8660
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
Of Counsel:
Thomas C. Spring, Esquire
1130 Seventeenth Street, N.W. Suite 400
Washington, D.C. 20036
IN THE UNITED STATES CLAIMS COURT,
Case No. 581-88T
CHURCH OF SPIRITUAL TECHNOLOGY,
Plaintiff,
v.
THE UNITED STATES,
Defendant.
PLAINTIFFS’ PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT
| I. CST’s FORMATION AND ITS PURPOSE | 1 |
| II. THE SCIENTOLOGY RELIGION AND ITS SCRIPTURES | 4 |
| III. L. RON HUBBARD’S BEQUESTS TO CST, RTC, AND CSI | 13 |
| IV. CST’S ORGANIZATION AND STAFF | 22 |
| V. CST’S ACTIVITIES | 30 |
| VI. CST’S FINANCES | 59 |
| VII. CST’S RELATIONSHIP WITH L. RON HUBBARD AND THE HIERARCHICAL CHURCH | 71 |
| VIII. CST’S ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDING BEFORE THE IRS | |
| A. CST’s Application For Recognition of Exemption And the Administrative Proceeding Up to the Initial Adverse Ruling | 102 |
| B. The Initial Adverse Ruling | 106 |
| C. CST’s Protest of the Initial Adverse Ruling | 109 |
| D. CST’S 1987 Conference | 112 |
| E. CST’s First Supplemental Submission | 114 |
| F. CST’s Second Supplemental Submission | 117 |
| G. The IRS’s Questions Regarding CST’s Relationships With Other Entities | 120 |
| 1. FBI and Armstrong Cases | 120 |
| 2. Religious Research Foundation (“‘RRF”‘) | 122 |
| 3. Cancorp Investment Properties, Inc. “‘Cancorp”‘) | 122 |
| 4. The International organizations | 123 |
| The On-Site Review | 130 |
| The Aznaran Summons and Interview | 152 |
| The IRS’s Termination of the On-Site Review | 166 |
| The Final Adverse Ruling | 172 |
INTRODUCTION
This document represents the proposed findings of fact of plaintiff, Church of Spiritual Technology (“CST”), in support of its brief on the merits filed herewith. In these proposed findings and in its brief, CST has used the identification and pagination conventions in defendant’s February 5, 1990, Motion for Leave to Give Notice of Citation Forms. Although these proposed findings incorporate portions of CST’s prior proposed findings made in connection with defendant’s
2
motion to dismiss and CST’s cross motion, no cross references to corresponding paragraphs of CST’s prior proposed findings have been included CST has prepared a separate Appendix (in 3 volumes) of relevant record materials which support these findings.(note 1).
The structure of section 7428 dictates that the facts in CST’s administrative record must be accepted as true.(note 2)
Thus, the facts set forth in these proposed findings must be accepted as true unless the record does not support the proposed finding or the record contains other facts which contradict the proposed finding. It should be noted that CST’s administrative record and proposed findings cover a larger period of time than the typical section 7428 case. Ordinarily, the IRS’s ruling with respect to a newly-formed applicant will be based only on its proposed activities. Here, however, because of the lengthy administrative proceeding prior to the IRS’s ruling on CST’s application, CST’s record includes not merely its proposed activities but evidence of its actual activities from its formation through April 30, 1987, the end of its 1986 fiscal year. Thus, in most cases, the proposed findings and CST’s brief describe CST’s actual activities rather than proposed operations. The findings and brief generally speak in the present tense, even though the activities described evolved over several years.
(note 1) In the case of certain lengthy materials, CST’s Appendix includes only those pages of particular exhibits pertinent to the proposed findings for which they are cited and additional pages necessary for context. CST’s Appendix does not include those exhibits which are cited merely for the fact they are in the record and not for their content.
(note 2) See National Foundation, Inc. v. United States, 13 Cl. Ct. 486 (1987); Easter House v. United States, 12 C1. Ct. 476 (1987); Church of the Visible Intelligence That Governs the Universe v. United States, 4 C1. Ct. 55, 60 (1983).
[…]
Notes
- This document in PDF format. ↩︎