MICHAEL J. FLYNN
ROBERT W. JOYCE, P.C.
ADAH ROSE BITTERBAUM
MICHAEL A. TABB
December 9, 1985
OF COUNSEL
WILLIAM A. SHERIDAN
Federal Bureau of Investigation
JFK Building – Room 900
Boston, MA 02203
GA letter to FBI (December 9, 1985)
Re: Gerald Armstrong
Your Ref. No. 47-4569
Dear Sir/Madam:
The purpose of this letter is to correct the FD 302 Report of November 4, 1985 prepared by your office, a copy of which is attached hereto and provided for your reference.
Par. 2: I have been in the United States, except for Portland, Oregon. I have not resided in Vancouver, B.C. since 1970.
Par. 3: Change “C” organization to “Sea Organization.”
Par. 4: Add to the final sentence: “that he knew to be a representative of COS.”
Par. 5: The lawsuit was brought by COS in August 1982. My function regarding the biography to be done of L. Ron Hubbard was researcher. The biography was to be written by Omar V. Garrison. The counterclaim was not tried in 1984. COS’s suit against me was. The trial ended June 8, 1984 and the decision was issued by the Court on June 20, 1984. The counterclaim is scheduled for trial in September 1986.
Please insure that all agencies or files which received the original report of 11/4/85 are forwarded a copy of these corrections.
Thank you for your attention.
Very truly yours,
Gerald Armstrong
GA/led
Enclosure
U.S. Department of Justice Federal Bureau of Investigation1 In Reply, Please Refer to File No. John F. Kennedy Federal Building Government Center Boston, Massachusetts 02203 November 20, 1985
Gerald D. Armstrong Law Offices of Flynn & Joyce 400 Atlantic Avenue Boston, Massachusetts 02210
Dear Mr. Armstrong:
This is in further response to your Freedom of Information – Privacy Acts request for information concerning yourself.
A search of the indices to the central records system in the Boston Office of the FBI discloses one main investigative file responsive to your request. Enclosed are copies of fifteen pages from this file. Excisions have been made and five pages withheld in their entirety in order to protect material exempt from disclosure by Title 5, United States Code, Section 552 and/or 552a:
(j) (2) Material reporting investigative efforts pertaining to the enforcement of criminal law including efforts to prevent, control, or reduce crime or apprehand criminals, except records of arrest.
(b) (7) Investigatory records compiled for law enforcement purposes, the disclosure of which would:
(C) Constitute an unwarranted invasion of the personal privacy of another person.
(D) Reveal the identity of an individual who has furnished information to the FBI under confidential circumstances or reveal information furnished only by such a person and not apparently known to the public or otherwise accessible to the FBI by overt means.
If you desire, you may submit an appeal from any denial contained
herein. Appeals should be directed in writing to the Assistant Attorney General, Office of Legal Policy (Attention: Office of Information and Privacy), United States Department of Justice, Washington, D.C. 20530, within thirty days from receipt of this letter. The envelope and the letter should be clearly marked “Freedom of Information Appeal.” Please cite the name of the office to which your original request was directed.
Very truly yours, JAMES W. GREENLEAF Special Agent in Charge By: [Signed] Edward W. Ludemann EDWARD W. LUDEMANN Assistant Special Agent in Charge
This letter is to confirm conversation between you and Special Agent (SA) XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX on October 30, 1985, during [handwritten: j2 b7c] which you were appraised of the facts of the above-captioned matter, and stated you would decline prosecution.
Enclosed are copies of the following:
1) A copy of complaint received at Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Boston office from Complainant XXXXXXXXXX [handwritten: j2 b7c]
2) A copy of letter from XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX , XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX , to [handwritten: j2 b7c] XXXXXXXXXXXXX , dated October 22, 1985.
3) A copy of a self-explanatory FD-302 reflecting the interview of Gerald D. Armstrong on October 23, 1985.
4) A copy of a letter from Gerald Armstrong to SA Leonard, dated October 25, 1985, with an enclosed Declaration of Gerald Armstrong. [handwritten: j2 b7c] [handwritten: Close (5) 11/13/85]
ENCLOSURES
1 – USA, Boston 1 – Boston (47-4569) XXXXXX XXXXXXX [handwritten: j2 b7c]
[handwritten: j2 b7c] XXXXXXXXXXXX
5) A copy of a letter from XXXXXXXXXXX to SA XXXXXXXXX [handwritten: j2 b7c] dated November 6, 1985.
The above enclosures are provided for your information. This captioned matter is considered closed. Sincerely, JAMES W. GREENLEAF Special Agent in Charge
By: XXXXXXXXXX [handwritten: j2 b7c] Supervisory Special Agent
Geller & Weinberg
ATTORNEYS AT LAW –
Eighty Boylston Street Suite 910
Boston, Massachusetts 02116
(617)482-5200
November 6, 1985
Geller letter to FBI (November 6, 1985)
Tim Leonard, Special Agent
Federal Bureau of Investigation
JFK Federal Building
Government Center
Boston, MA 02203
Re: Gerald Armstrong
Dear Mr. Leonard:
When you called my office on October 21, 1985 concerning the complaint of Mitra Hall about Gerald Armstrong you indicated to me that you would advise me after you had spoken to Mr. Armstrong.
It has now been more than two weeks since our call. Have you contacted Mr. Armstrong? Did he admit to his violation of the Federal statute? Was he told of the criminal consequences of his actions? Will he be prosecuted?
I look forward to your response to these questions.
GERALD D. ARMSTRONG, Paralegal at FLYNN & JOYCE Law Offices, 400 Atlantic Avenue, Boston, Massachusetts, telephone (617) 350-7200, was interviewed. ARMSTRONG was advised as to the official identity of the interviewing Agent, the nature of the interview, and subsequently provided infor- mation as follows:
ARMSTRONG stated he recently arrived in the United States as a resident in Boston, Massachusetts, on September 5, 1985. He advised that prior to that he had resided in Vancouver, British Columbia, for a number of years.
He stated that he became a member of the CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY (COS) in early 1969 and remained an active member until the year 1981. He further advised that during this period he did extensive travelling while a member of the “C” organization within the church.
He stated that he has never identified himself to anyone as a Special Agent for the FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION (FBI), nor has he identified himself as a Federal official to anyone since he has resided within the City of Boston. He stated he has had no contact with anyone from the COS since he arrived in Boston. However, he advised that approximately two weeks ago he accompanied Mr. FLYNN to an oral proceeding which took place at the Federal Courthouse, Boston, where there were a group of protesters that appeared to be representatives of the COS in the lobby. He advised he did not have any contact with the representatives of the Church that day. He further advised that no representative of the COS has approached him on the street since he has arrived in Boston.
ARMSTRONG stated that in the year 1981 the COS brought suit against him concerning papers that were found pertaining to L. RON HUBBARD, Founder of the COS, while he was in charge of HUBBARD’s holdings. He advised that after finding these papers he worked up a biography of HUBBARD. ARMSTRONG stated he left the COS on December 12, 1981. He further stated that he filed a countersuit against the COS,
Investigation on 10/23/85 at Boston, Massachusetts File # Boston 47-4569-3
by SA XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX [handwritten: j2b7c] Date dictated 10/29/85 [Stamped] SEARCHED
SERIALIZED XXXXXX
INDEXED
FILED XXXXXX [handwritten: j2 b7c]
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property of the FBI and is loaned to your agency; it and its contents are not to be distributed outside your agency.
FD-302a (Rev. 11-15-83)
BS 47-4569
Continuation of FD-302 of GERALD D. ARMSTRONG, On 10/23/85, Page 2
which went to trial from April to June, 1984. He advised that the trial ended on June 20, 1984 with a significant decision in his favor.
When asked again, ARMSTRONG stated that he has never represented himself as an employee of the FBI to anyone at any time.
Background information was obtained through observation and interview as follows:
Geller & Weinberg
ATTORNEYS AT LAW –
Eighty Boylston Street Suite 910
Boston, Massachusetts 02116
(617)482-5200
November 1, 1985
Tim Leonard, Special Agent
Federal Bureau of Investigation
JFK Federal Building
Government Center
Boston, MA 02203
Re: Gerald Armstrong
Dear Mr. Leonard:
Letter from Roger Geller to FBI (November 1, 1985)
When you called my office on October 21, 1985 concerning the complaint of Mitra Hall about Gerald Armstrong you indicated to me that you would advise me after you had spoken to Mr. Armstrong. It has now been almost two weeks since our call. Have you contacted Mr. Armstrong? Did he admit the incident occurred? Was he told of the criminal consequences of his actions? Will he be prosecuted?
I look forward to your response to these questions.
I, Gerald Armstrong state and declare under the pains and penalties of perjury as follows:1
1. I was in Scientology from 1969 to 1981. I worked personally for L. Ron Hubbard during much of that time, and was personally appointed by Hubbard to be the researcher on a proposed biography of his life. During my work on that biography I assembled many documents concerning almost all of Hubbard’s life, and discovered that he had extensively lied about his education, credentials, past accomplishments, his role in Scientology, and Scientology itself. When I tried to work within the organization to make the truth known in a manner which would least damage Scientology and Hubbard, organization officials claimed I was an enemy trying to destroy the founder.
2. After I left the organization I was declared a “suppressive person” and subjected to the “Fair Game” doctrine. The organization began a “Black Propaganda Campaign” aimed at destroying my reputation. They initiated a covert intelligence operation against me, stole photos I had, and when I demanded their return told me to get an attorney. Fearing I would become the target of costly and harassive lawsuits, and believing my life and my wife’s life were in danger, and needing to defend myself, I contacted attorney Michael Flynn. I obtained from the author for whom I had done the biography research, copies of some of the documents I had seen while working on the biography project and I sent these documents to Mr. Flynn. The documents proved that what I had been saying about Hubbard was true and they showed a massive fraud on his part.
3. Scientology sued me, and after a five week trial in the California Superior Court it was ultimately determined that I was justified in sending the subject documents to my attorney. The Court stated in its decision, a copy of which is attached as Exhibit D to this opposition:
“…just as the plaintiffs have First Amendment rights, the defendant has a constitutional right to an attorney of his own choosing. In legal contemplation the fact that defendant selected Mr. Flynn rather than some other lawyer cannot by itself be tortious. In determining whether the defendant unreasonably invaded Mrs. Hubbard’s privacy, the court is satisfied the invasion was slight, and the reasons and justification for defendant’s conduct manifest. Defendant was told by Scientology to get an attorney. He was declared an enemy by the Church. He believed, reasonably, that he was subject to “fair game.” The only way he could defend himself, his integrity, and his wife was to take that which was available to him and place it in a safe harbor, to wit, his lawyer’s custody.” 2
4. The knowledge that I have and the documents that I have seen are particularly damning to Hubbard and Scientology. Based on them, in part, Judge Breckenridge in his opinion in Church of Scientology of California v. Armstrong, C420 153, found that “the Church or its minions is fully capable of intimidation or other physical or psychological abuse”, it “abuses its own members civil rights”, “the organization over the years with its ‘Fair Game’ doctrine has harassed and abused those persons not in the Church whom it perceives as enemies”, L. Ron Hubbard is “a man who has been virtually a pathological liar when it comes to his history, background, and achievements” and Scientology’s “practice of culling supposedly confidential ‘PC folders or files’ to obtain information for purposes of intimidation and/or harassment is repugnant and outrageous.” All of these findings were made by Judge Breckenridge in the case Scientology brought against me.
5. In order to compromise my effectiveness as a witness and undo the Breckenridge judgment, Scientology created the “Armstrong Operation”. It was a Scientology setup from the start. I was contacted in June of 1984 by an old friend of mine who told me that a group of individuals called the “Loyalists” were seeking to reform the organization, and end the criminal and tortious activities and the Fair Game doctrine. My friend said the “Loyalists” had existed for two years, they had people on staff in the organization and many others who supported their cause. The “Loyalists” wanted my help because I had contacts among other individuals who opposed the organization’s practices, and because I had been successful in litigating against the organization. They wanted me to act as their consultant.
6. I had several meetings with representatives of the “Loyalists” and was even taken to meet an attorney whom they said was going to file a lawsuit on their behalf to oust what they called the “criminal management’ of Scientology. Unknown to me, these meetings were covertly and illegally videotaped. The entire operation was a setup. The “Loyalists” had no intention of ending the organization’s illegal activities and were not planning to file a lawsuit. They were a fictional creation to make it look like I was conspiring to overthrow Scientology.
7. The videotapes do not reveal all of my conversations with the “Loyalists”. Scientology has chosen those parts which it feels are most beneficial to them. Even the videotapes they do use do not show what Scientology claims. They simply reveal conversations about ideas proposed by the “Loyalists” for their use in their struggle. Of course, since the “Loyalists” never really existed, nothing was ever carried out. In any event, the wild claims Scientology makes, that I conspired to plant false documents, steal privileged information, and set up some sort of sexual blackmail situation, are ridiculous. Judge Lander, in the case of Christofferson v. Scientology, et al, in Portland, Oregon recognized that the tapes do not say what the organization says they say. He stated, immediately after viewing the tapes on April 4, 1985:
“I think they are devastating. I think they are devastating against the Church. We certainly view them in a different way, Mr. Cooley, you and I.”
…”it borders more on entrapment than it does on anything else. How a sophisticated person, which Mr. Armstrong purports to be, could go for such an amateurish performance as I heard on these tapes is beyond me. The questions were being fed to him obviously; anytime he wanted to make an explanation, it was promptly cut off. There was no evidence of any attempt to commit a crime that I saw.”3
In fact, on the tapes themselves, in response to a suggestion by one of the “Loyalists”, an operative named Mike Rinder, that false documents be created, I reply, “I wouldn’t touch it with a barge pole.”4
8. Despite Scientology allegations to the contrary, I was not acting as an agent of Michael Flynn, or various government agencies when I met with the “Loyalists”. I simply was responding to the “Loyalists” request for help from me, and I accepted their offer to help me out. They actively encouraged me to request all sorts of things, claiming they could get whatever I needed. Any requests I sent them I originated on my own. Neither Michael Flynn nor the federal government asked me to obtain any documents or information for them from the “Loyalists”. In fact, Michael Flynn cautioned me that the “Loyalists” might be an operation created by Hubbard.
9. Under California law, an individual cannot be videotaped without his consent. Scientology, at the Christofferson trial, claimed that a private investigator hired by them, Eugene Ingram, (who had been kicked off the Los Angeles police force for various offenses) obtained an authorization to secretly tape me from a police officer. In an official statement released by the Los Angeles Police Department, however, LAPD Chief Daryl Gates stated that the officer had no authorization, and that it would be “a cold day in hell” before the Los Angeles Police Department cooperated with Eugene Ingram. A copy of this announcement is attached hereto as Exhibit A.5 I have learned from Commander Booth of the LAPD that the officer involved, Phillip Rodriguez, was suspended for six months due to his improper “authorization”.
10. If this court has any doubts about this entire illegal affair, I urge it to view the tapes themselves. They will plainly show that the Scientology charges are ridiculous and grossly inflated. It will also prove to the court that Scientology engages in precisely the types of covert criminal and tortious operations in violation of individuals’ rights which its critics have alleged it has committed for years.
Signed under the pains and penalties of perjury this 1st day of November, 1985, in Boston, Massachusetts.